Share of Voice: Are Companies Obsessing Over the Wrong Metric?
Leah Dergachev • November 1, 2024
Stop counting mentions, start measuring impact: Why the most-tracked marketing metric might be leading you astray
PR and marketing teams everywhere are chasing Share of Voice (SOV) like it's a golden ticket. They're investing heavily in content creation, social media presence, and PR campaigns to boost their numbers. But is all this SOV obsession actually helping businesses grow?
Let's break down why SOV both matters and might be leading companies down the wrong path.
When Share of Voice Hits the Mark
SOV isn't without merit. When brands dominate industry conversations strategically, it creates a powerful ripple effect. Brand recognition increases, consumer recall strengthens, and market presence grows organically.
The metric can reveal valuable insights about market dynamics:
- Emerging industry trends
- Competitive movement
- Campaign effectiveness
- Market opportunity gaps
Where SOV Misses the Point
Here's the reality check: having the loudest voice in the room doesn't necessarily mean having the most influence. Think of brands that dominate industry chatter but struggle with customer loyalty, or smaller brands with devoted followings despite lower SOV.
Several key issues make SOV a problematic north star:
- Volume doesn't equal value: High mention counts might mask negative sentiment
- Context gets lost: SOV doesn't capture whether conversations drive business results
- Quality takes a backseat: Meaningful engagement often matters more than quantity
- Industry differences: Some sectors benefit more from trust than visibility
The Strategic Shift Companies Need to Make
Rather than obsessing over SOV, successful brands are taking a more nuanced approach:
- Measuring what matters: Engagement rates, sentiment, and revenue impact tell a fuller story
- Prioritizing audience connection: Creating valuable conversations over maximizing mention counts
- Understanding industry dynamics: Adapting metrics to what drives success in specific markets
- Building meaningful presence: Focusing on quality interactions that drive business growth
A Better Way Forward
The most effective approach treats SOV as one instrument in a larger orchestra of metrics. Companies seeing the best results are:
- Combining SOV with deeper engagement analytics
- Focusing on conversation quality over quantity
- Aligning social presence with business objectives
- Measuring actual customer impact
The Real Bottom Line
Share of Voice matters—but it's not the marketing messiah many make it out to be. True market leadership comes from creating value for audiences and building genuine connections that drive business growth.
While SOV can indicate market presence, it's the quality of that presence that ultimately determines success. Companies that understand this nuance are better positioned to create meaningful market impact rather than just noise.
Making Metrics Work Harder
To get more value from SOV tracking:
- Set clear, business-aligned objectives
- Choose relevant measurement channels
- Look beyond raw numbers
- Connect metrics to outcomes
- Adjust strategy based on insights
Marketing success isn't about who talks the most—it's about who says what matters to the right people at the right time.
Fear of AI replacing marketing and communications professionals runs rampant. But this misses the real opportunity: leveraging AI as a powerful ally that handles repetitive tasks while you focus on what truly matters – creativity, strategy, and human connection. From Replacement to Enhancement The "AI will steal your job" narrative fails to recognize a crucial distinction – AI transforms roles rather than eliminates them. For marketing and communications experts, this transformation offers unprecedented possibilities to elevate your work. Practical Ways to Implement AI in Your Marketing Arsenal Content Development Acceleration How to implement: Draft email newsletters by providing AI with your key points and tone requirements Create multiple headline variations based on your target audience segments Transform basic outlines into full blog drafts that maintain your voice Repurpose existing long-form content into social media snippets Implementation tip: Save your best-performing content as examples for the AI to learn your style. Include specific instructions about brand voice and audience needs for more accurate results. Research and Insights on Steroids How to implement: Extract key findings from market research reports in seconds Analyze customer feedback across platforms to identify recurring themes Compare competitor messaging strategies by having AI review their content Monitor industry conversations to spot emerging trends before they peak Implementation tip: Frame specific questions when using AI for research. Instead of "tell me about our industry," try "What are the three emerging challenges our target audience is discussing in relation to [specific topic]?" Productivity Systems That Actually Work How to implement: Create detailed content calendars based on your strategic goals Generate meeting agendas and capture action items automatically Draft client proposals using past successful examples as templates Organize research sources and extract relevant quotes and statistics Implementation tip: Build templates for recurring tasks. For instance, create a template for client report generation with placeholders for metrics, insights, and recommendations. Where Human Expertise Remains Irreplaceable While implementing these AI tools, recognize that certain aspects of marketing and communications remain distinctly human: Strategic thinking that connects business goals to audience needs Creative problem-solving that breaks through market noise Emotional intelligence that informs authentic messaging Building genuine relationships with clients and audiences Understanding cultural contexts and sensitivities in communication Your Five-Step Implementation Plan Identify your time suckers: Track your activities for a week to find repetitive tasks consuming your creative energy. Choose one AI tool to master: Rather than dabbling in many, become proficient with a single tool that addresses your biggest pain point. Create an AI-human workflow: Establish a clear process where AI handles first drafts and you provide critical refinement. Measure impact beyond time savings: T rack not just hours saved but improvements in output quality, client satisfaction, and your own job fulfillment. Implement learning blocks: Schedule 2 hours weekly to experiment with new AI applications relevant to your specific marketing needs. The Augmented Marketing Professional The distinction between AI-enabled marketing professionals and those who resist these tools grows wider daily. The competitive advantage lies not in working harder but in working smarter through strategic AI implementation. By focusing your AI implementation on eliminating the mundane aspects of your role, you can invest more deeply in the strategic thinking, creativity, and relationship building that truly drive marketing and communications success. The question isn't whether AI will take your job – it's whether you'll use AI to transform your role into something more impactful and valuable than before.
Transform Customer Testimonials into Powerful Narratives That Build Trust and Drive Growth
Stop chasing trust and start earning it with these proven strategies to make your brand the go-to authority in your industry
Essential PR strategies and tactics for startup success in today's digital media landscape
The Power of Seeing What Others Miss
Practical Tips to Elevate Your Startup's Social Media Game
The Secret Connection Between Great Marketing and Market Demand
Speak Your Brand's Truth in Every Digital Language
A Guide for Growing Your Business and Your MarTech Stack
Imagine this: you're at a networking event and everyone's talking, laughing, sharing stories. You have something important to say, so you start speaking. But, with everyone consumed by their own conversations, nobody turns to listen. That's not great, is it? Well, welcome to the world of content creation in 2024. Everyone has a platform and a voice, and standing out just isn't about being heard, it's about being worth being heard. Today, we're diving into a critical truth that could revolutionize your approach to content creation: content without strategy is just noise. The Content Conundrum We're all passionate about our products, brands, and messages. The urge to share our thoughts and creations with the world is strong. But before you hit that "post" button, pause for a moment and ask yourself: "What value does this actually bring to my audience?" Think about it. We're all drowning in a sea of content every single day. Social posts, articles, videos – you name it. The internet is a cacophony of voices, all vying for attention. So how do you make your content stand out in this crowded space? Quality Over Quantity The answer isn't about volume. It's about purpose. Quality content always starts with a crystal-clear purpose. Before you even begin creating, ask yourself: Are you solving a problem? Are you entertaining your audience? Are you educating them? Are you inspiring action or change? Know your "why" before you create your "what". This approach ensures that every piece of content you produce has a specific goal and delivers real value to your audience. Respect Your Audience's Time Remember: Your audience's time is precious. In an age of information overload, attention is a scarce commodity. By creating purposeful, high-quality content, you're showing respect for your audience's time and energy. Make every piece of content count. Aligning Content with Strategy The next time you're planning your content calendar, take a step back. Look at the bigger picture: Align your content with your overall business goals. Understand your audience's needs, pain points, and desires. Create with intention, ensuring each piece of content serves a specific purpose. From Content to Conversations Think of it this way: You're not just creating content, you're crafting conversations. Every post, article, or video is an opportunity to engage with your audience in a meaningful way. It's a chance to build relationships, establish trust, and provide value. So next time you're creating content, make sure you have a strategy in place, too. It's what transforms your messages from mere noise into valuable, engaging communications. By focusing on purpose and quality, you'll not only stand out from the crowd but also build a loyal, appreciative audience. With content creation, less can often be more – as long as that "less" is purposeful, valuable, and aligned with both your goals and your audience's needs. So, are you ready to elevate your content strategy? It's time to create with purpose and watch your audience grow.
